Elemental Qualities in Astrology

This in-depth article, by leading astrologer Ian Thurnwald, outlines the traditional system of elemental qualities as it applies to the Astrological elements and to the triplicities of the signs and the seasons of the year. Ian also develops a new method based on Aristotle's conceptions of "being and becoming" to apply the seasonal qualities in a more meaningful way to Southern Hemisphere births.

In the first place, I hope to show that this original means of classifying the signs helps us to gain more understanding of the basic nature of the signs of the Tropical zodiac. Secondly, we shall explore the obvious implication of this seasonally based system for people born in the southern hemisphere, namely, that with the reversal of the seasons in the southern hemisphere the expression of the signs is altered somewhat. Finally, I'd like to demonstrate a practical use for this system, as a way to delineate basic temperament from natal charts.

Here I am drawing on J. Lee Lehman's (1996) ideas from Chapter 3 of Classical Astrology for Modern Living: From Ptolemy to Psychology and Back Again. (Whitford Press: Atglen, PA). The main points of Lehman's argument are as follows:

• The elements as used in Astrology are of Classical Greek origin and have the same meaning as they had in Greek cosmology and science. For the Greeks just about anything, from natural processes to human temperament, could be classified as being of the nature of either air, fire, earth, or water.
  
  
• The Greeks, however, always utilised two sets of opposites, the elemental qualities, hot and dry, cold and wet, to describe the elemental components of whatever they were categorising. An example of the reasoning would be; steam is predominantly active (hot) and formless (wet), so it is of the nature of air.
  
  
• The most complete version of this system was put forth by Aristotle around 350 B.C.E.. Aristotle proposed that the elements were combined of the qualities in such a way that one element could change into another through a cyclic process. The model for this process of change was the cycle of the seasons.
  
  
• These ideas were fully developed before Astrology entered the Greek world. This is one reason why Astrology was so readily taken up by Greek intellectuals of the day.

The Elements as Modes of Behaviour

Aristotle's Model of Being and Becoming

ELEMENT	Being and Becoming	QUALITY
Air	WET becoming hot	wet & hot
Fire	HOT becoming dry	hot & dry
Earth	DRY becoming cold	dry & cold
Water	COLD becoming wet	cold & wet

The Elemental Qualities

ELEMENT	ZODIACAL SIGNS	QUALITY	HUMOUR
Air	Gemini, Libra, Aquarius	hot & wet	Sanguine
Fire	Aries, Leo, Sagittarius	hot & dry	Choleric
Earth	Taurus, Virgo, Capricorn	cold & dry	Melancholic
Water	Cancer. Scorpio, Pisces	cold & wet	Phlegmatic

Implications for Astrology

• Signs that are hot in nature, the fire and air signs, put out energy and are quick to act, their focus is on the people and things around them, they are excitable and behave in an enthusiastic manner.
• Signs that are cold in nature, the earth and water signs, draw in energy and are slow to act, their focus is on their own thoughts and feelings, they are controlled and behave in a dispassionate manner.
• Signs that are dry in nature, the fire and earth signs, are tense and nervous, they relate by differentiating themselves from others; they think in an analytical or concrete way, by making distinctions, breaking bonds and separating things out into their unitary parts.
• Signs that are wet in nature, the air and water signs, are flexible and relaxed, they relate by connecting with others; they think in a creative or abstract way, by blurring boundaries, making connections and bringing things together as a unified whole.

As to the second point, using the elemental qualities in Astrology shows us that a crucial relationship is established between the elemental qualities of the seasons and the signs. Moreover, it is this that accounts for the differences in expression between signs of the same element. For example, the fire sign, Aries, is inherently hot and dry, but it falls in the hot and wet season of Spring, so Aries is hot and slightly wet. These distinctions can be more clearly seen in the table below:

Sign	Element	Elemental Qualities	Seasonal: North	Seasonal: South
	Fire	Hot & Dry	Hot & Wet	Cold & Dry
	Earth	Cold & Dry	Hot & Wet	Cold & Dry
	Air	Hot & Wet	Hot & Wet	Cold & Dry
	Water	Cold & Wet	Hot & Dry	Cold & Wet
	Fire	Hot & Dry	Hot & Dry	Cold & Wet
	Earth	Cold & Dry	Hot & Dry	Cold & Wet
	Air	Hot & Wet	Cold & Dry	Hot & Wet
	Water	Cold & Wet	Cold & Dry	Hot & Wet
	Fire	Hot & Dry	Cold & Dry	Hot & Wet
	Earth	Cold & Dry	Cold & Wet	Hot & Dry
	Air	Hot & Wet	Cold & Wet	Hot & Dry
	Water	Cold & Wet	Cold & Wet	Hot & Dry

In the table we can see, for example, that all the fire signs are by their very nature hot and dry. However, the addition of the elemental qualities of the seasons results in differences between the fire signs. Leo being the midsummer sign gets a double dose of hot and dry and is the pure fire sign, but Aries being a Spring sign is wetter (hot & dry, hot & wet), and Sagittarius being an Autumnal sign is colder (hot & dry, cold & dry). Obviously, this both explains and helps us to better understand the differences between signs of the same element. In the case of the fire triplicity, we see that: Aries is as active (hot) as Leo but it is more sociable (wet by season) than either Leo or Sagittarius; that Sagittarius is as discriminating (dry) as Leo but it is less assertive (cold by season) than either Aries or Leo, and; that Leo is the pure fire sign—it puts a lot of energy (hot) into establishing its own distinctiveness (dry).

Tropical Astrology in the Southern Hemisphere?

Air Signs:

• Gemini is the pure air sign in the north (hot & wet, hot & wet), but in the south it becomes a mixed sign having all the qualities (hot & wet, cold & dry). A southern Gemini then, is less energetic and has all four qualities to express. This Gemini tries to be all things to all people.
• Libra in the south is the pure air type, the ultimate air sign; an enthusiastic type that likes to move about and socialise. This Libra is the "life of the party".
• Aquarius in the north is basically wet (hot & wet, cold & wet), however in the south it much warmer and drier (hot & wet, hot & dry). A southern Aquarius then, is very energetic and is more of an "ideas person" than a "team player".

Fire Signs:

• Leo is the pure fire sign in the north (hot & dry, hot & dry), but in the south it becomes a mixed sign having all the qualities (hot & dry, cold & wet). A southern Leo then, has all four qualities to express but with less energy to do so. This is a more relaxed and genuinely gregarious Leo.
• Sagittarius in the north is basically dry (hot & dry, cold & dry), however in the south it is much hotter and wetter (hot & dry, hot & wet). A southern Sagittarius then, is a very energetic sign and is more sociable than its northern namesake.
• Aries in the north is basically hot and wet (hot & dry, hot & wet), however in the south it is colder and much drier (hot & dry, cold & dry). A southern Aries then, is less energetic and more dogmatic than its northern namesake.

Earth Signs:

• Taurus in the north is a mixed sign, warmer and wetter than one would expect of an earth sign (cold & dry, hot & wet). But in the south Taurus becomes pure earth (cold & dry, cold & dry). A southern Taurus then, is quite staid, materialistic and insular.
• Virgo in the north is basically dry (cold & dry, hot & dry), however in the south it is much colder and wetter (cold & dry, cold & wet). A southern Virgo then, is less energetic, less critical and more sociable than its northern namesake.
• Capricorn in the north is basically cold and wet (cold & dry, cold & wet), however in the south it is warmer and much drier (cold & dry, hot & dry). A southern Capricorn then, is more active, more realistic and less sociable than its northern namesake.

Water Signs:

• Pisces is the pure water sign in the north (cold & wet, cold & wet), but in the south it becomes a mixed sign having all the qualities (cold & wet, hot & dry). A southern Pisces then, has all four qualities to express but has a little more energy to do so.
• Cancer in the south is the pure water type, the ultimate water sign; low energy, flexible, communal.
• Scorpio in the north is basically cold (cold & wet, cold & dry), however in the south it is as warmer and much wetter (cold & wet, hot & wet). A southern Scorpio then, is slightly more active, less analytical, and more sociable than its northern namesake.

Elemental Qualities and Temperament

Since the elemental qualities apply to the signs we can also say that they apply to the planets placed in the signs of the horoscope. A practical application of this system, then, is that we can list the sign placements of the planets in a natal chart and tally up the elemental qualities of the planets by sign, as well as by season, to see what overall characterisation better fits the person.

By way of an example, let's look at President George W. Bush's planets in terms of the elemental qualities:

Planetary Qualities in President George W. Bush
Planet	Sign	Elemental Quality by Sign	Elemental Quality by Season: North or South
Sun	Cancer	cold & wet	hot & dry
Moon	Libra	hot & wet	cold & dry
Mercury	Leo	hot & dry	hot & dry
Venus	Leo	hot & dry	hot & dry
Mars	Virgo	cold & dry	hot & dry
Jupiter	Libra	hot & wet	cold & dry
Saturn	Cancer	cold & wet	hot & dry
MC Mid-Heaven	Aries	hot & dry	hot & wet
ASC Ascendant	Leo	hot & dry	hot & dry
Part of Fortune	Scorpio	cold & wet	cold & dry
RESULT		hot & wet or hot & dry	hot & dry

In terms of the elemental qualities of the signs, the President's temperament is an even balance between sanguine (hot & wet) and choleric (hot & dry). However, when the elemental qualities of the seasons are taken into consideration Bush is most definitely choleric—a fiery type, a high energy person who acts to express his own power and will in the world.

In support of the sanguine characterisation, it could be said that 'dubbya' has a certain way with words! He also seems to get along very well with the Russian President, Mr Putin (a Libran). On the choleric side, however, Bush keeps fit by 'pumping iron' (very choleric), and his leadership style is that of the company director—he relies on advisers to understand and analyse issues, then makes his decision on the basis of their findings—not a particularly sanguine approach.